A bandana is a piece of either square or triangular cloth which is generally worn around the neck or head. Although it can be styled as a fashion item, the bandana also offers several practical uses. The shemagh is similar to a bandana in many ways, but is usually much larger, offering greater coverage and protection in extreme conditions. Previously seen as a predominately eastern phenomenon, the Shemagh has, in recent years, seen a rise in popularity in the western world, particularly among survivalists, hikers, and the military.
Many users find the bandana a very useful item. However, those looking for an alternative would do well to consider the shemagh. Although both garments share several characteristics (both offer protection, coverage, and have practical purposes that extend beyond a simple item of clothing), fans of the shemagh claim the garment fulfills the promise of the bandana with added extras, offering better protection, better coverage, and advanced multi-functionality.
The bandana, too, comes with its own set of die-hard fans, who cite its versatility, availability, and practical functionality as just some of the reasons for its superiority.
Choosing between the two can be tricky, and so we are faced with the question is a shemagh better than a Bandana?
Unquestionably, both the bandana and shemagh offer numerous benefits to the wearer. Some of these benefits are common to both garments, but there are unique aspects to each. Of course, personal style will play a role to some extent, but the most important thing to remember when deciding between the two is the function you need the garment to serve.
For example, the shemagh may work best in extreme conditions where you need full protection from heat, wind or sand. The bandana, on the other hand, may be better in more temperate, public environs, where full coverage may be more of a hindrance than a help.
Read on to discover why neither the bandana or shemagh is necessarily better than the other, and why deciding between the two is simply a matter of perspective.
For one of the best rated Shemagh on Amazon, click here. Alternatively, for those who favor the bandana, I have one here that is highly recommended. Please click here to get the latest pricing.
Environment
When deciding between a shemagh or bandana, the first thing to consider is the environment you’ll be wearing it in. The shemagh, being considerably larger than the bandana, offers greater protection and coverage. It would, therefore, be the best choice in extreme heat, wind, or desert conditions.
The bandana, on the other hand, offers less coverage, making it ideal for more temperate environments. Being a smaller piece of cloth, the bandana covers less of the face than the shemagh, making it the better choice if an unobstructed view is important (for example, if you are planning on hunting or climbing).
The bandana may also be the preferable option if you’ll be wearing the garment in public places; the shemagh has, in recent years, developed an unfortunate association with terrorism, and would, therefore, be a less than ideal choice in crowded areas.
Versatility
One of the greatest advantages of the bandana is its versatility. Not only can it be worn in a variety of different environments, but it can also be worn in a multitude of different ways. It can be folded into a thick band and worn as a sweatband; worn half turban style; tied around the neck as a scarf, worn as a hairband… the variations are endless. Aside from the many ways of styling a bandana, it can also serve several different practical functions. Rolling a bandana and tying it around the forehead will keep sweat from dripping into your eyes. It can also be used as a makeshift filter to remove impurities and dirt from drinking water.
The ways of styling a shemagh are more limited, but this doesn’t mean it doesn’t serve a variety of different purposes, making it an exceptional tool in survival conditions. The large size of the shemagh makes it an ideal bandage for wounds; wrap it around the wound enough times to ensure adequate pressure on the wound to stem bleeding. If you’re setting up camp in a wooded area, wrap your food and toiletries in the shemagh and hang it off a high branch. This will keep wild animals from stealing your provisions.
The shemagh can be fashioned into a makeshift sling if you hurt your arm. If necessary, it can also be used as a signal flag. Tie it around a stick and wave it back and forth to attract the attention of rescue workers; its large size will make it noticeable even from a distance.
When it comes to versatility in styling, the bandana is the clear winner; for versatility in functional uses, the shemagh takes first place.
Size
Depending on the situation, keeping baggage to a minimum is a vital consideration. Carrying too many items can weigh you down, making certain activities difficult, or even dangerous.
The shemagh tends to be larger and weightier than a bandana. This may not be important if you plan on wearing the scarf most of the time, but it’s certainly something to consider if you’ll be carrying it around your arm or in a bag for any extended periods.
The bandana, being lighter, smaller, and available in a wide range of lightweight cloths, would, therefore, seem the preferable option if you want to keep excess weight to a minimum.
Survival Uses
Environment, size, and versatility are all important considerations to bear in mind when it comes to choosing between a shemagh and a bandana. However, depending on the situation you’re facing, it’s also vital to consider the practical, survivalist functions of both garments.
Both bandanas and shemaghs can be used to remove dirt or impurities from water, making it safe to drink. However, the larger sized shemagh can hold considerably more water, making it the better choice for drinking or carrying water over distance.
The size of the shemagh also makes it the preferable option as an emergency bandage, providing enough material to wrap and protect wounds of most sizes.
As a rule, the shemagh is larger and stronger than the bandana, making it more useful across a wider range of situations. Bandanas tend to be made of weaker material, making it easier for them to rip apart or tear. The shemagh on the hand is incredibly tough and resilient and is undoubtedly the better of the two at holding up against heavy strains.
Why Not Both?
Although interchangeable in some situations, both the bandana and shemagh have unique properties. This makes the bandana preferable over the shemagh in some cases, and the shemagh preferable over the bandana in others. This begs the question of why even try to choose between the two? If both are useful, why not carry both?
If you can, taking both will certainly give you the best of both worlds, and will equip you to deal with almost any situation you find yourself in. However, carrying both does have its downside. Weight is, of course, an important consideration in many situations.
If you’re hiking or camping, you’ll want to minimize your carrying load as much as possible. Packing additional items, even if they might be useful, is something you’ll want to avoid. In these instances, it is vital to consider which of the two options is the best fit for your environment and the potential situations you could face. Once you’ve considered the possibilities, choose your preference accordingly.
Final Thoughts
As we’ve seen, both the bandana and shemagh offer many advantages. There is no one answer to the question of which is best; the best choice is really going to depend on your own personal preference, the environment you’re facing, and the practical uses for which you’ll be employing the garment.
If you’re traveling on a hot, sunny day in a desert environment, the shemagh may the better choice. Equally, it may be preferable of the two if you need a multi-function item in extreme conditions. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a lightweight option to keep the sun out of your eyes; if you’re traveling in cooler weather; or if you simply want to avoid drawing too much public attention, a bandana will be the better fit.
Before deciding between the two, give some thought to your individual situation. Is a lightweight option more important than functionality? Will the weather be extreme or mild? Will you be traveling in remote, desert environments, or will you be in public for much of the time? Once you understand your unique requirements, making the right decision will be that much easier.
Click here to get the latest pricing on a highly rated shemagh on Amazon. And for those wanting to stick with the good old bandana that I highly recommend, click here